Legoland New York and Rye Playland are two amusement parks located in New York state that are incredibly different experiences. Rye Playland is a classic amusement park with a lot of history while Legoland New York is a modern and highly themed experience.
So which park should you visit?
I am going to weigh the positives and negatives of each park to help you determine if you should plan a visit to one, both, or neither of the parks. The comparison will be split into sections looking at theming, roller coasters, dark rides, other attractions, and overall park experience.
Theming
Both parks feature a good amount of theming but in incredibly different ways.
Legoland New York is a new theme park that emphasizes highly themed attractions throughout the entire park. It features defined themed areas that are very different from one another, and every building in the park is tied into the immersive Lego theming.
Playland on the other hand features a classic Art Deco style design throughout most of the park combined with some well-designed landscaping. In areas that still maintain the original feel of the park, it feels like stepping backwards in time with its classic architecture.
But the entire park is not themed like this, with some areas merely being a collection of rides placed on pavement that looks more like a traveling fair than a permanent amusement park. Roughly half the park is well themed while the other half is merely a collection of rides with little to no theming.
Both parks do feature a lot of theming, but Legoland's is more consistent and modern than the classic and inconsistent theming at Rye Playland.
Roller Coasters
Playland has more roller coasters than Legoland, but they are not necessarily better overall.
The Dragon Coaster at playland is a classic wooden coaster with some strong moments towards the beginning of the ride, but it is far from the best wooden coaster out there, but it does have some classic style theming.
Beyond that ride though, none of the roller coasters at Playland are standouts. Crazy Mouse is a fun wild mouse style coaster, but not different than any other roller coaster of a similar style. Super Flight is a ride that is more painful than enjoyable, and beyond these, the other coasters are all kiddie rides.
Legoland New York meanwhile only has two roller coasters, both themed after Dragons. The Dragon is a steel family coaster that begins with a dark ride segment before featuring a traditional family coaster style section. It is a good ride that is intense enough to be enjoyed by adults without being too scary for children tall enough to ride it.
The Dragon's Apprentice meanwhile is a kiddie coaster with some minimal theming.
Both parks really have one strong coaster, both themed after dragons. Playland just has more overall coasters.
Dark Rides
Both parks have some highly themed dark rides, but they are incredibly different attractions.
Playland has three dark rides and all of them are classic dark rides. Two of the three, Zombie Castle and The Flying Witch are incredibly similar horror-themed dark rides. Ye Olde Mill on the other hand is a well-done highly themed (by the standards of the park) dark ride that has a fun story and good animatronics.
Legoland New York only has two dark rides, but they are much more modern and elaborate dark rides. Lego Factory Adventure Ride is a great trackless dark ride with a fun story and good theming and a small simulator-like element that is an exclusive attraction to this park. Lego Ninjago The Ride is a great 3D shooting dark ride attraction with an interesting interactive element. Both are incredible modern dark rides that rival Disney in terms of quality.
It is difficult to compare these two parks for their dark rides because they are both good at what they offer, but they feature incredibly different experiences.
Other Attractions
Beyond the roller coasters and dark rides, both parks offer a collection of other attractions.
Legoland New York focuses on a collection of themed flat rides with interactive Lego theming, with highlights including the Splash Battle and the Miniland walkthrough area. It also features a fun 4D theater attraction that is a great experience.
Rye Playland meanwhile has a combination of classic and modern unthemed flat rides with standouts including the two water rides as well as the Steeplechase attraction. But the rides here do skew older than at Legoland, both in terms of their age and in terms of the people who would want to ride them, although there is a land for small children.
Both have really equal collections of rides, the question is if you want theming.
Overall Park Experience
In terms of overall park experience, there is really no question which park has the advantage.
Playland focuses on individual rides, and they do have some incredible rides, but Legoland focuses on the entire experience and even with only a single year of operation under their belt they excel at it. With better food offerings, shows that are on theme with the park, near-constant character appearances, and more they focus on the full-day experience.
Legoland does fall short in one key area though, and that is shade. There is no shortage of shade at Playland, with most queue lines and even some pathways covered from the elements. Legoland meanwhile, being a new park, has no large trees and relatively few artificial shade structures. The park does have more indoor attractions, but with the park's sprawling and hilly layout, it is impossible to find shade in massive areas of the theme park.
You really can have a great day at both of these two parks. Playland offers a wonderful classic amusement park experience with tons for young and old guests to do. Legoland New York is perfect for families and provides a modern theme park experience that is fun for young and old. They are each great parks, but very different from each other.
Follow Theme Parks and Entertainment On Instagram
Comments
Post a Comment